Should they become provinces and autonomous regions, and form a unitary state (like PRC) or should they become constituent Republics and form a Federation (like the USSR)?

  • cfgaussian@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    11
    ·
    5 months ago

    The question isn’t what should happen it’s what can happen. What is actually politically feasible? If the choice is not between unitary state and federation but between federation and continued division then the answer is clear. I think federation is easier initially, and from that point the government can still be gradually centralized, because federations tend to be unstable and less efficient at governing and defending themselves. This is something that very likely will have to be a gradual process.

  • RedNajm [none/use any]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    5 months ago

    Im arab and will try to speak on an arab state (I am biased, since I am in favor of the idea). This is absolutely not possible in the next 40 (very optimistic view) years, but will be set in the far future.

    It’s a very multi faceted problem tbh. But i think it can be split into three big ones, concerning the peninsula, levant and north africa:

    The peninsula should be one. It’s less historic/cultural difference that there’s multiple monarchies, but political (and British fuckery of course). Yemen is more complex. I don’t want to speak confidently, but from my limited understanding, I think a republic composing of the entire peninsula is still the best choice (?). Provinces at least, maybe.

    It gets complex with the levant and especially north africa. While they are all arabs, they have different conditions. It’s made up of republics (and Jordan) who, despite the modern nations being artificial created after the dissolution of the Ottomans and British/French occupation, they still have roots in actual history, and it can’t be waved away as easily as the Peninsula’s monarchies (i.e. Palestine, Iraq, Syria off the top of my head). There’s also the fact that it has more minorities than the Peninsula. The Kurdish, Yazidis, Assyrians, Circassians. (These are the non-Arab minorities. There are arab minorities such as the Druze and Alawites) In fairness, China is very ethnically diverse too, however the PRC is not based on Han-nationalism. My armchair professional solution? Republics (the Peninsula would be a republic too alongside it, as a reference)

    North Africa is the hardest, imo (I know the least about their conditions, so it may not be actually hard but just me not knowing enough lol). However they’ve had the most major Arab nationalist movements, so it’s not impossible. Off the top of my head, there’s the Copts, Berbers (and all the history and differences inbetween) and Nubians. I won’t touch on this too much, but in this scenario, they’d either not be included in the Arab union (unlikely? Egyptian/Libyan history for ref) or be included as republics?

    I think the best answer would be a federation that would integrate overtime. a complete Arab nation despite pan-Arabism, would have to be very diverse politically (not that it’s contradictory, but explicitly noting) Of course this is assuming it would be state-atheist/secular, a unitary islamic republic across the whole three regions would implode in civil war in 3 seconds lmao. I’m curious how the historic ML Arab parties thought of Arab nationalism however.

    Thank you for coming to my ted talk. I think about this question a lot to myself honestly and would appreciate Arab comrades on lemmygrad for corrections and thoughts.

  • opiumfree@lemmygrad.mldeleted by creator
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    5 months ago

    i think its up to the people in there. countries have their own histories and a union is not feasible sometimes because it would end in an uproar of civil wars and ethnic tensions