Jeanne-Paul Marat

Nimrod who forgot their password and had to make a new account.

Young American Orthodox Marxist-Leninist Nucleocrat. Han Suyin’s biggest fan. Jacobin [in the based way and not in the american liberal way] and friend of the people. Any pronouns are fine, but prefer she/her or they/them

Elaboration:https://lemmygrad.ml/post/10116673

Original account:https://lemmygrad.ml/u/King_Simp

Substack:https://open.substack.com/pub/journaldemarat?r=2lr83e

  • 6 Posts
  • 21 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: December 19th, 2025

help-circle

  • For a much more in depth explanation, I reccomend Cheng Enfu’s “China’s Economic Dialetic.”

    Basically the three main things id argue are

    1.they are, but given how reliant on international trade they are, they’d rather do it gradually and through economic pressure than through polticial mandate. This can be seen in how SOE’s have been told to compete on the market more, which they will have a natural advantage with.

    2.China wants to have a primary-secondary distribution system. I.e, by 2049 they want to have a distribution based on work system be primary, but with a supplemental market system to make up for deficits. Then later after that move to a need based system with distribution by work to make up deficits

    3.Id argue socialism in one country is…economically oversimplified, but not in the Trotskyite way. What I mean is that, even at China’s size, they cant have everything. And in my interpretation of marxist longue durée dialectical materialism, a full proper transition to the higher stages of socialism can only occur as the rest of the world transitions to socialism [i.e, how the Dutch practiced capitalism but still fell behind to feudal france and such]. Additionally, development of automation [just as the development of industrialization before it] will probably greatly speed up this process once it is more viable


  • I think the problem with the purge was not necessarily those who were purged, but that there was no next generation to replace them.

    Yes in China Deng survived, but honestly from what ive seen of Bukharin im not sure if the two are entirely comparable. But the crucial thing is that there was a generation of CPC members that could survive the turbulence of reform and opening up, the June 4th incident, etc.

    This wasn’t just the purge of course, given ww2 took more CPSU members, but if you look at China, the DPRK, and Vietnam compared to the USSR and eastern Europe, id say its the people’s ability to have faith and interact with the system that led to their survival compared to eastern Europe’s downfall.


  • Its hard to say exactly, since I think the collapse of the USSR is probably one of the best examples where Marxist Longue durée analysis should be used.

    However, if I can try at least

    1.Preventing Krushev’s secret speech/takeover in general

    This is probably the lynchpyn of the whole thing. You had many young comrades coming into the party [most notably Yeltsin and Gorbachev] and Krushchev’s first act would essentially shatter faith in the system high and low, much as how the Thermidorian reaction shattered the revolutionary spirit of france and gave way to Bonapartist cynicism.

    Not only that, but the so called “anti-party group” generally had the better economic policies, and more experience.

    2.An earlier Detente if possible

    Obviously this is as much the west’s ball game as it was the USSR’s. But putting so many resources into the military was one of the leading reasons of the decline. The Cuban missile crisis, ironically enough, was probably a missed opportunity for more comprehensive agreements on the matter.

    3.The party remaining connected to the people

    This one is a bit obvious, which is why its here instead of at the top. But the problem that occured with Perestroika is that the USSR was like a pressure cooker. There needed to be some way to release the steam and there never was. Breshnev was probably a really good example here of what not to do. His period in office didnt solve problems, leading to this pressure build up.

    This also goes for eastern Europe in general tbh. Although I do agree with soviet intervention in the most high profile incidents, so im not sure about that tbh.

    Overall what probably killed it most was the sino-soviet split, which, while Krushev was important, was brewing from the days of the internationale. [The third int is its own topic I’ll probably talk about one day though]



    1. This is not directed at you, but AI is such a shit term. Its just too broad and I feel like it feeds into that tech/finance bro thing of making things sound more complex than they actually are.

    2.Im not super anti-ai, but I wouldn’t publish anything with ai in it. At least in my experience it’s not great. For brainstorming or personal use it’s fine, but for public consumption I’d just make it myself

    3.The idea of ai “proletarianizing” artists is just really wierd. Its a very, very tiny amount of the world population who make their income from art commissions online or making murals and such. Other artists actually make income by being part of teams, whether that is game design, movies, TV, advertising, etc.

    4.I do stand by what I said that ai art just has a fundamental flaw of being unable to generate anything new (as in, ai could not make a new art form or movement. It couldnt make realism if you gave it all the romantic paintings, for example), meaning that human artists, even individual artisans, still have to exist.

    1. Honestly, it’s just ugly a lot of the time. I’m not saying that it might not get better, but seeing so many on social media is honestly not very great. Not even because i have a personal crusade against it, and I get why people in china (for example) like it, but I do honestly think it looks like crap in a very unnatural, uncanny valley way.

    Edit: also, ai summarizing articles and books for people is just stupid. Youre missing the point if you read an ai summery of something, same if you were to read the cliff notes of something (except the ai is probably gonna do worse anyway).

    Edit 2: It’s good for coding, at least as someone who isn’t good at coding. That’s something reasonable to publish with ai, because it makes a lot of sense why ai is good at it (for the most part, although at the same time to my knowledge on larger projects you spend as much time bug fixing as you would writing the code without ai)


  • I’m biased because this is what happened to me personally, but the wierd lack of power combined with high emotional responsibility.

    If someone has too little power but also not much responsibility, they’re usually spoiled but not mentally unwell. [I.e, a kid who has their parents baby them and do everything for them]

    Someone who has too much responsibility but also a lot of power/independence is hurt by not having a childhood but they do still know how to be an adult [i.e, someone with negligent parents who needs to work to provide for them]

    What I got was no power [helicopter mom, constantly paranoid about everyone else, basically anything she said went and I could never fight it or argue anything, and if something went wrong it was my fault, never had an independent income until i became an adult, etc.] but also way too much responsibility [Emotionally supporting her, having to be her therapist, having to deal with my emotions myself, having to make sure everything was in tip top shape so she didn’t have a mental breakdown and scream at me, having to solve her interpersonal disputes, etc.]. So i wasn’t able to be a kid emotionally but also didn’t know how to be an adult. Combined with dehabilitating anxiety, suicidal thoughts and actions, and literal ptsd, I think that’s my least favorite type.


  • Personally I don’t know any Muslims. Not because I don’t want to, just that I haven’t had the opportunity to.

    Personally I think its…“underappreciated” in the west. Which is a light word considering the treatment, but just that there’s a lot of Islamic history that just isn’t taught here despite its importance. Additionally I really couldn’t tell you much about it even though it’s one of the biggest religions in the world.

    However I do have my concerns about how central Islam is to a lot of middle eastern politics today. It feels bad that a lot of secular Baathism (it’s flaws not withstanding) has kind of fizzled away in favor of things like the Muslim brotherhood, the Turkish AKP, Shia-revolutionism



  • Both of those are mostly watched by younger viewers to my knowledge, oversimplified especially. I would say they “pad the gaps” per se. History education is notoriously shit in the USA, so these type of channels are less Robert Conquest and more trivia night, if that makes sense. Oversimplified, Mr.Beat, extra history, etc. Mostly serve to be broud strokes about lessee known history, foreign history, or just general overviews for those that aren’t super well informed.

    As for me, I did watch these channels when I was younger and definitely wasn’t as critical of them as I should have been, but I did grow out of it. Extra history and Mr.Beat are still decent if you’re curious about something that isn’t important. I think my biggest gripe is when they’re the most popular or even only source for something online. For example, the French revolution has some documentaries and some others, but by far the most popular English source on yt is oversimplified. Given my username, you can assume my feelings on him. Conversely there is extra history’s sun Yat-Sen series which is…decent, from what I can tell.

    I will say, despite the numerous flaws, some information is still better than no information. I’ll let Samuel Clemens take it away,

    "When I finished Carlyle’s French Revolution in 1871, I was a Girondin; every time I have read it since, I have read it differently being influenced and changed, little by little, by life and environment (and Taine and St. Simon): and now I lay the book down once more, and recognize that I am a Sansculotte–And not a pale, characterless Sansculotte, but a Marat. Carlyle teaches no such gospel so the change is in me–in my vision of the evidences.

    People pretend that the Bible means the same to them at 50 that it did at all former milestones in their journey. I wonder how they can lie so. It comes of practice, no doubt. They would not say that of Dickens’s or Scott’s books. Nothing remains the same. When a man goes back to look at the house of his childhood, it has always shrunk: there is no instance of such a house being as big as the picture in memory and imagination call for. Shrunk how? Why, to its correct dimensions: the house hasn’t altered; this is the first time it has been in focus."

    -Twain In a letter to William Dean Howells [although to compare these channels to any of these great authors is not a one to one comparison]


  • Mmm, I’m not well versed enough on Christian theology or the social influence of Christianity as opposed to other world religions.

    However I would say that if we are supposing Christian teachings are at play here, it would more likely be the Christian “reward for adversity and prayer” doctrine [I’m not sure what the proper name for this is].

    I’m stealing this from a liberal show [the west wing] but I think it encapsulates the point we’ll enough. “A man lives in an area plagued by storm. The man prays every day for safety. First, he hears on the radio that there is a storm coming and that he needs to evacuate, but he stays put and prays for God to protect him. Then, a fireman comes and tells him he needs to evacuate, but the man doesn’t and says God will protect him. Then, as the storm approaches, a helicopter arrives and the man is once again implored to evacuate, and once again he says no because God will protect him. The storm comes and the man drowns. When he arrives in heaven he asks God ‘Why didn’t you save me?’ And god replies ‘I tried, I sent a radio broadcast, a fireman, and a helicopter.’”

    I think it’s more that kind of thinking that you’re looking for rather than martyrdom



  • You’re putting bicycle wheels on a truck, if that metaphor makes sense.

    “Political power grows out of the barrel of a gun” is not the same as “might makes right” although they can be seen as similar.

    Might makes right is the justification of victory, of opposition or the lack there of. It’s the language of colonizers, that if someone was a victim, they should have just been strong enough to resist. That, by virtue of victory, the victor is correct. It’s a cyclical argument, the law of the jungle.

    “Political power grows out of the barrel of a gun” is less about what makes something right or wrong, and more simply about the facts. Communists aren’t right because they defeat capitalism through revolutionary violence, but revolutionary violence is still necessary.



  • Obviously Vance would become president, but you know that already.

    I would think something would change though. Take a look at Marco Rubio and cuba currently. Trump said there are negotiations, when there in fact aren’t any.

    I think Trump as a personality engages with the world more as a business. He goes up to a country and says “we will invade and destroy you and blah blah blah” and basically goes super high on his demands. Then he negotiates “down” when in reality he’s basically getting his original deal because his original demanda were so outlandish.

    But Rubio currently is basically trying to annihilate cuba. Him and his cohort don’t want a deal with Cuba, rather he wants Cuba’s government overthrown.

    Trump’s strategy plays much better to his personal ego, but I think Vance would possibly be closer to the classic “neo-con” strategies.

    Theres also the possibility he’s just very incompetent or impotent, being essentially in a PR position as VP and if, Trump dies before Vance’s next birthday, he’d be the youngest president in history, beating out T Roosevelt by one year.


  • You’re assuming things about op that can’t be gotten from the post. How do you know their lineage? They could be descended from any number of people who didnt enjoy those spoils either. The only thing is that they’re “wealthy” enough to go to college and emmigrate.

    Also, exodus of skilled workers has been a weapon employed by the imperialist nations for decades now. From east Berlin to former yugoslavia brain drains have been an active threat. Why can’t progressive people act in the same way?

    And it’s a wierd catch 22, you’re not allowed to leave and live in a self sufficient country that doesn’t rely on mass imperialism, but also if they live in the imperial core they’re morally responsible for the system they were born into.



  • Hyper moralism is certainly the indication of a good ideological understanding.

    Snideness aside…what? What type of fucking logic is this? Don’t try to…improve your life? What? If the chinese people allow immigration, then what goddamn moral grandstanding is it to be like “no they shouldn’t let you in because you’re profiting off their hard work.” Thats not marxist logic, that’s not even any logic. It’s pure foolishness. People are up voting this complete garbage? Did people here get concussed between yesterday and now?

    Edit: This is also coming from the same people who are like “oh America will never have a revolution ever” or just “nuke america.” People wondered why i had that outburst a couple months ago and this is why.









  • [Note: twchnically was a social democrat, but i dont really care seperating soc-dems from dem-socs] I was really, really bad for a while. Like “no country should be trading with China or Russia” bad. Like “supports israel” bad.

    For me it was A. The disparity between the socialist response to covid to the rest of the capitalist world and B.Radicalization from learning about the Iraq War.

    I lost a family member to covid, and when that million death toll rolled around, i was incensed. I was even more incensed because I warned everyone in my life and online about the disease, and i got the ever so often “don’t worry about it, it’s just the cold.” I essentially watched in reverance as China managed to do a full response while being a much more densely populated country and being where the outbreak originated from.

    The Iraq War was another one. For me, Vietnam was bad, but that was just “bad strategy.” I still saw it as legitimate (obviously I don’t believe that now). Iraq was always “the war.” It wasn’t taught in schools, I didn’t even know any vets from the war. I knew we invaded Iraq, but I didn’t get why it was so controversial. I was looking at it and wondering, since the intial engagement didn’t actually last that long [unlike Vietnam, kind of. Obviously there were the Iraqi insurgents]. One day i finally looked into it and it essentially shattered me. So much death and destruction for what is basically money for people who already had money. And no one got punished for it. At that moment I basically vowed that I wouldn’t believe anything the media or western stooges put in front of me. Of course this led to some embarrassment [a la, Sadam Huissein and Pol Pot support], but after some ideological ironing it helped smooth out those wrinkles.

    Note: I had an inkling of a sense of political economy. At one point i even remember grumbling to myself like “why do the corporations get to have all this power and get rid of jobs and dwvelop/impoverish places based on tax policies, but the workers have to put up with it?” That was way before the events mentioned above, i just find it funny looking back on it