• 29 Posts
  • 51 Comments
Joined 2 年前
cake
Cake day: 2024年8月8日

help-circle


  • Entirely plausible, great summary.

    The russian capacity to swallow their own bullshit is maybe the only thing that is truly bottomless about them. Lies don’t matter. Truth doesn’t matter. They just stick with a narrative - like that they single handedly defeated the germans in WW2. Never mind the fact that their low functioning grunt hordes wouldn’t have had boots, much less weapons, if not for Lead Lease. Reality never factors in to how they choose to feel about their own importance.

    They kind of have a point if you squint hard enough. There never, ever was an external threat to Russia other than China and there isn’t now. They shattered their otherwise useless, aging Soviet hardware inheritance and liquidated useless mouths and undesirables in exchange for good Ukrainian land. Not as much as they wanted - but…land is land.

    It really doesn’t matter what they say. That’s not for our consumption. Russia’s future is bleak and unstable as a junior vassal to China, with a dying population and permanently degraded economy. Ukraine’s future is that of other post-Soviet states Poland, Romania, the Baltics - EU aligned, sovreign and prosperous.

    Let them yap. And fuck off home to cannibalize themselves.


  • It’s really incredible what Ukraine have done to save not just their own country, but the damage that Russia intended to wreak across the world.

    Russia clearly intended to brutalize Ukraine and then pivot to the Baltics, Moldova, Probably even get a bite of the bigger fish like Kazakhstan, Poland and Finland. The machines and men chewed up over the last few years were clearly intended to be part of the next phase of Imperial Russian restoration.

    And if Russia had been successful, China would likley have already launched an invasion of Taiwan while Comrade Krasnov does his part to keep the U.S. uninvolved.





  • You’re citing his words as though they ARE the real drivers for why any of this war is happening. Rolling back nato expansion, historic grievances, blah blah blah. I’m saying that the reason he invaded is much likely just pure, vicious greed and glory. All the talk of NATO expansion, ukrainian Nazis, even restoration of russian empire is just horseshit.

    They wanted money, land, glory and people (well…slaves). The same prizes that have motivated barbarian gangster warlords for thousands of years. Whatever word salad they put forth as justification is totally irrelevant.

    Behind closed doors, they probably have a more realistic timline and terms. But Russia’s brutalist psyche has to go through the absurd theatrics of maximalist demands to pretend they’re strong. Since this will almost certainly end up as a ceasefire where they get far less than they wanted, the peace terms will be blamed on lower level bureaucrats. It doesn’t matter what Putin claims their terms are - where this war ACTUALLY settles out will be totally detatched from that crazy overpromoted gangsters’ public statements.

    The Russians have already moved a LOT from their original demands. They will move more before this is over, but you have to roll your eyes and endure suffering for a while longer before the shooting stops. Russia HAS to go through these absurd pantomime negotiations precisely because their war goals have fallen so short. But their strategy for the last few centuries has been to demand everything, concede nothing, and sit there awkwardly until the peace-worshipping pussies in the west GIVE you something you didn’t have before to make the horror stop. But that strategy only worked because of the implied threat of what Russia might do if you didn’t give them something. You know - the way of a terrorist.

    But that Ol’ Reliable strategy of ‘give me something’ might not be useful when their army is objectively shattered. If negotiations fail - Russia continues to bleed with no realistic prospects for them to suddenly kick the war machine into antoher gear and make a final push on Kyiv. This was ALWAYS a war of national conquest. it wasn’t supposed to get bogged down at the Donbas borders and only seize the southern strips of Zaporhizia and Kherson that they are on now. At a MINIMUM they wanted everything east of the Dnipro, AND the entire southern coastline of Ukraine to Odessa. Both to link up with their Moldovan colony, to eliminate Ukraine’s ability to export grain via the Black sea to make their agricultural export industry unviable.

    Rebuilding it to the 2021 levels of menace will take more years than Putin probably has left to live. Ukraine isn’t in a state where they need to even consider the absurd terms russia is asking for now. If Ukraine continues to bleed the russians, the terms will change. Quickly. Putin’s words in the context of peace terms are irrlevant. What russia will actually accept isn’t going to come from his mouth.









  • By design - lots of people have reminded us this is the Russian Way of negotiations. Maximalist demands.

    Demand more than everything, and yield nothing. Then sit there in uncomfortable silence until they offer you something you didn’t have before, because they always do. Because feckless pussies in the west value peace more than you do. This is the negotiation tactic of terrorists, of course. Give us something or else.

    That only works though, if they truly fear your potential brutality. But - what else can Russia do that it hasn’t already done to Ukraine? It’s possible there is a limit to their ‘give me something’ stonewalling. They’re dying in vastly irreplaceable numbers right now and not achieving anything substantial in the process.

    The past success of Russia’s maximalist demands was predicated on fear of what the Russians might do if you didn’t give them something. Not only can they not be trusted to keep their word, but we’ve seen all they can do. There’s really not much they can do to escalate further, which really erodes their childish position. China isn’t going to allow them to use nukes, nor should you use nukes against a) your neighbor or b) land you claim is yours.




  • Can’t see either side agreeing to formal territorial concessions. Neither has such an overwhelming advantage at present that one gets to dictate to the other. Just like Korea - there’s a demarcation line and the shooting stops, but no official peace treaty. Neither side is happy with what they currently hold, after all.

    Devil’s advocate - Ukraine getting territory back is a longer term prospect. They’ve lived without Luhansk and much of Donetsk and Crimea for 12-15 years already. Doesn’t seem likely Ukraine has the open disregard for it’s own soldiers’ lives that would be required to make a large scale push in the near term to regain big pieces of territory. And a post-putin power struggle may present less bloody ways to make that happen - either the territory itself, or allow more favorable and safe terms for the ukrainian-inclined populations of those areas to return to Ukrainian held land. Human capital is extremely valuable to both of these countries given their already poor demographics trends.

    The conditions for land reclamation may be better later than they are now.



  • In past way-above-aveage casualty surges, it was becase the goblins had started an offensive and smashed their thick skulls against the fortress belt harder than usual. Nobody on either side is reporting larger than usual offensives at the moment, nor is it the time of year to do so.

    Makes you wonder what’s different recently, if these numbers are reliable (no reason to suspect they aren’t). Is Ukraine keeping OpSec on it’s own counter offensives? Drone production or deployment efficiency increase? The leaves falling off trees reducing overall canopy cover?







  • Exactly. Ukraine has multiple paths to victory. Russia has none. This isn’t a board game where all the Russian pieces have to be moved across a line for them to have lost.

    Russia would have been way, way smarter to declare a ceasefire after the 2023 Kherson counter offensive by the Ukrainians. They would still have all the territory they’re still on 3 years later, they wouldn’t have lost another million men and god knows how much equipment. They could have said “we’ve made our point about our security”, declared that NATO had chickened out to fight them, blah blah blah.

    Ukraine’s counteroffensive had just failed, their backers might have said “this is the best we’re gonna get”, Russia would have been reintegrated to the global economic system by now. Ukraine wouldn’t have gotten to the point where they could attack their oil industry, wild berries/ozon and their data centers.

    But - nope. They’re greedy idiot pigs, so they have spent 3 more years dying and getting weaker and weaker.