• 1 Post
  • 386 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: September 15th, 2025

help-circle

  • Definitely not Stockholm syndrome. I work in the industry and have seen all of this from the inside :P

    For the record, we can’t say how much net profit Rockstar made, only the gross revenue for the platform sales so far. We have no idea how much they spent developing and marketing the game. The number you’re seeing in headlines is just units sold multiplied by retail pricing. It does not take into account licensing and platform fees either.

    To say it plainly: Rockstar did not make anywhere near $3bn in profit.

    It’s also notable that they are self-published. Most studios don’t publish their own games; they either have publisher funding or their parent company publishes it (if they’re owned by one of the big players). So that’s an additional cost that other studios usually have to pay back.

    I do agree with you about the layoffs. But that is at least emergent from economics of capitalism; in a capitalist economy, for games that require years of development and have multiple-hundreds-of-millions budgets like GTA, the system we have for how games are funded ultimately demands the layoffs, because there is no guarantee that even DLC will keep people employed after the main release. There are just too many roles that only exist during production, not post-release (and DLC never requires the amount of the staff that a base game needs; it’s not like all the people who were needed to build and test online services have work to do on the DLC)

    And to be clear: if your complaint is that games cost too much in general, that’s a different discussion (something I still disagree with but has very different arguments). But for “premium content” I really can’t get behind anything other than “you either feel the extra content is worth the extra cost or you don’t” and not stuff like “any day one dlc/extras should just be included in the base game”.


  • It costs nothing? You think people weren’t paid for their time to work on it?

    That DLC was produced by people who got paid for their labor. You are literally asking the company to reduce their margins. If the decision was made to have no day one dlc the content wouldn’t be included in the base game, they simply wouldn’t make it, wouldn’t hire the extra people needed to make it.

    I’ve said this before: whether you agree with the value proposition of the base game, and whether including the dlc would change your opinion of that value proposition is a separate issue. Tell me “this base game isn’t worth $60, but it would be if they include the dlc” and you’re making a reasonable argument. “They should include the dlc in the base game because it’s finished at launch time” on the other hand is not a reasonable argument.



  • No, that is not what I’m saying: that is part of my point, but you stop short of the actual point.

    The actual point is that those things roughly determine the ratio between production cost (both in dollars and time) and value to the customer.

    It’s about what it requires to produce a given amount of gameplay/time entertained.

    Here’s an even simpler one: development time. Average was less than a year for NES games, and up to 3-5 years today.

    All of these things are typically drivers of retail pricing in other industries. But videogame pricing has been more or less stagnant for a very long time. And it’s the reason games have turned to alternative revenue streams that people hate


  • Yes, this is why they create the extra content. But that doesn’t make the base game “incomplete” or “not the full game”.

    The appropriate measure to use is “Does the base game feel like an incomplete game or below value for the price?”

    If you have to pay for the ending, that’s not the full game.

    If you have to pay for a unique weapon, skin, it side quest, that’s a full game with extra content for purchase.

    There is no world in which the dev/publisher releases the content in the $100 version for $80. Even if there was no tiering, they would just cut that extra content from development to save budget, not add it to the base game.

    Deliverables are planned with budgets that take the retail pricing into account.




  • They are a reasonable proxy for production-cost-to-entertainment-hours conversion.

    The quality of a game is in the eye of the beholder. And there are good games that cost almost nothing to make, and there are shit games that cost millions to make.

    The point I’m making is about how much money it typically costs to create an hour of playable content.

    It obviously varies greatly from game to game, based on the type of game, replayability, etc, and actual appeal

    But it is reasonable to say that, on average, player expectations for games have gone up over the last 40 years, meaning lines of code per hour of entertainment has gone up, hours spent working on assets per hour of entertainment has gone up, etc.

    So, on average, we’re paying more to make 20 hours of gameplay today than we were 40 years ago.

    It’s not about “more lines of code = better game” or anything like that.

    It’s about what it costs to make an hour of content, and what players will pay for that hour of content. Which translates directly to how many players you need in order to turn a profit. Which translates directly to funding struggles for anything but nearly guaranteed hits.


  • Yup. That’s exactly what I’m talking about. It’s insanely cost effective. An order of magnitude more cost effective.

    Books might be the only thing comparable.

    And we’re not even talking about multiplayer games where you can sink literally hundreds or thousands of hours into 'em.

    Here’s another fun fact to put it in perspective…

    Let’s say I want to hire a team of 5 people full time to develop a game, and I expect it to take two years, and sell for $19.99 on Steam.

    All-up you’re looking at about $1.5M at least for that type of game, between employee compensation, marketing, operations, QA, and overhead.

    A reasonable estimate for net profit on a $19.99 PC game is around $7.49 per unit sold.

    Wishlist conversions in the first week after launch are about 10%. For a popular game, you might see 4x your first-week sales over the following 2-3 years.

    That means you need ~485,000 people to wishlist your game to recover a $1.5M investment after 2-3 years from launch.

    And under current economic conditions, publishers won’t fund the validation phase anymore. You have to build a demo or vertical slice and get that shit onto Steam so they can see the wishlist rates before they’ll fund full production.

    The economics of making games right now sucks. Yeah, games like Balatro can make a lot of money, but those types of breakout success are the exception. Most games released today don’t even come close to recouping their investment.


  • I’ve had really great kaiseki and really awful kaiseki.

    A) you get what you pay for

    B) Many kaiseki courses at traditional ryokans attempt to replicate a “modest”, traditional food experience. Historically, Japanese cuisine has not used very strong seasoning or flavoring, relying on the taste of the main ingredients alone. Many Japanese people still consider western cuisine to be bordering on “extreme” in terms of how powerful the flavors are.


  • 100% this.

    It gets even crazier when you calculate things like “$ per line of code written” or “$ per megabyte” and track it back to the NES.

    Video-games are exceptionally cost effective as entertainment, and gamers’ resistance to price increases is one of the reasons battle passes and micro transactions blew up. Despite what everyone thinks, it’s really hard to fund game dev these days because of the margins. Unless I’m willing to work for free for several years, i need an investor to put up around $1.5M to release a game as simple as Balatro.

    There’s plenty of corporate greed, and union busting, and all sorts of bad shit. But expecting a AAA game with a narrative/content driven experience over 20 hrs for less than $60 is fucking nuts


  • By this logic, the existence of premium model vehicles means that their lowest priced version isn’t the actual price of the vehicle.

    Tiered pricing for different variants does not mean you’re not getting the “full product”. It means you have the option to pay more for additional content.

    Once the DLC for a game is released, if they sell a bundle with the base game + DLC, is the base-game-only SKU ”not selling you the whole game"?

    That interpretation would be kinda absurd.

    You can have opinions about whether some content or another should’ve been in the base SKU or not based on price, but it’s absurd to say they’re not selling you the “full game” unless there are substantive elements missing that the game feel incomplete.


  • neatchee@piefed.socialtoPolitical Memes@lemmy.world•Welcome to the DNC
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    15
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    For the 117th time: He ran unopposed

    Unless some progressive is willing to stick their neck out, what the fuck else do you expect to happen? He ran unopposed

    Even AOC doesn’t want the job. Because Speaker for the House means owning all the procedural shit, and representing the interests of the entire Democratic caucus. AOC isn’t interested in the position because it would prevent her from pursuing her actual agenda.

    I don’t like Jeffries as Speaker. But he ran un-friggin-opposed.


  • Secret vote is such a misleading term to use here. It was a preliminary vote in a closed door session of the Democratic caucus only, before it comes to a floor vote. The purpose of the closed door vote is for Democrats to get aligned as a party so the floor vote isn’t fucked up.

    It’s not a secret. Nobody was trying to hide what was happening.

    There’s plenty to be upset about but that ain’t it



  • In addition to what other users have said about moderation, it’s also important to note that this follows the ActivityPub standard of “originating instance owns the content”.

    The ability to delete content that is offensive, problematic, or even regretted is something that’s really important for ActivityPub adoption. If the assumption is that any post you make cannot be retracted from the network it would create a significant disincentive to posting freely. “You own and control the content you create” is a major driving force for adoption of ActivityPub over centralized services.

    Obviously everyone knows that anything you post can be screenshot, saved, etc. But to some degree this can be managed with access controls and defederation from offending instances. It’s important that the default behavior be “propagate deletions/bans” to maintain the paradigm of “you own and control the content you create”.




  • That’s absolutely not true at all, IMO.

    Not all art is created for the purpose of creative expression. Much of the labor performed by artists is better classified as “communication”. It conveys information or ideas for non-creative purposes.

    Technical manuals have meaning without creative intent. The logo for your local pizza place has meaning without creative intent. Even things like application interface design can have meaning without creative intent (creativity in UI is actually a rare thing to need; mostly we’re building on established paradigms people are comfortable with. Sometimes creativity is needed and good but not always)

    So I fundamentally disagree with your premise as a rule. The type of art people are passionate about is creative art. But not all art needs to be creative.