When I imagine an effective sustainable general strike it starts to sound a lot like a revolution. We could imagine supporting a general strike that could be sustain to involve preparing by going to different groups working people and asking what it would take for them to join, and what they demands they would like to have. Nurse, farmers, cooks, drivers, engineers, etc., it, all would have a different perspective and need different to join. Not just the union reps but the actual people who do the work. We could ask all of them what demands we could make for a general strike that they would support. A local group of residents could distill the list of demands from everyone just to remove duplicates. Before strike day we could vote on the demands, about what we think actually belongs on the list. When we go on strike, we have almost a constitution. We would be able to sustain the strike indefinitely.
Short strikes rarely achieve much. Long strikes have this habit of turning into revolutions. Obviously organizing such a thing in the US would require months, but probably not years of work. Most people in the US want ICE to stop kidnapping people, want to stop money being spent to bomb children in our name, want data centers to stop raising our electric bills and stop spying on us, and most people in the US want people guilty of physical and r*** to face justice regardless of their net worth.
Most of the homeless people I’ve talked to have told me the worst thing about being homeless isn’t having nothing, but not being able to do anything for anyone else that is appreciated. I know that feeling very well, and I suspect most of us do. In this version of a general strike or revolution everyone would be working for each other, so no one would starve or go hungry. Everyone’s needs would accounted for if not met.
So is a general strike supported by mutual aid a revolution?
If you look at histories of revolutions, all of them involved strike actions. To my mind 1917 or Cuba come to mind. Sustaining such a strike would always be the biggest issue. The level of mutual aid needed would require the coordination of essentially a parallel government - in 1917 these were the soviets (councils of workers and soldiers). This is what Marxist-Leninists mean when they talk about building dual power - building the (mutual aid, etc.) capacity to be able to sustain a revolution.
In the US you can look at the black panther party as something that tried to build such a coordination, they ran kitchens and education and even a small paramilitary at times. They were quickly dismantled by FBI obviously because it presents an obvious threat. So that is also something to keep in mind, the state has to be sufficiently weakened for an alternative power to be able to rise.
I have noticed this as well. It’s becoming strikingly clear to me (no pun intended). It is said that Lyndon B. Johnson claimed the greatest threat to the US government was the Black Panther’s free breakfast program. I’m still digging through the documents to try to find the quote though.
A strike doesn’t seek to change the relation workers have with capitalists, only to achieve some progressive policy or reformist demands. A “social revolution” can include strikes, or evolve from strikes, but its main distinction is that it seeks to fundamentally change the relationship of workers and specifically their relation to private property and the means of production.
A strike is an action that can lead to a revolution, but itself does not inherently seek to fundamentally change these relations. Likewise a “political revolution” also doesn’t seek to change these relationships and thus despite being a revolution, only accomplishes reforms.
Its much like asking “what’s the difference between a wheel and a car” one is a component of a car but does not make a car. Likewise one is a component of revolution but does not mean revolution itself.
PSL has a nice description of this that quotes Marx’s definitions here if you like: https://liberationschool.org/what-is-socialist-revolution/
That is very valid point and I like that comparison of a wheel and car. I got lost in thinking how best revolutionary orgs can support strikes, because in my thought experiments it seems as though changing the modes of production would be the best way to support a strike. A diverse (in both profession and identity) group of workers who have all had a say in the demands that the strike is for and ready to work together because they have all been heard are essentially forming a new governance. Connecting, trusting and respecting one another despite the wildly cruel way the exploitation class attempt to divide us, can help the strike last much longer, and thus be more effective. However all of them “having a say” isn’t really part of the general strike, and agreeing to work with each other to promote the survival of the strike isn’t really part of the strike. Even a general strike just refers to denying capital our labour power. All that other stuff is just revolutionary support for a strike, like the engine and possibly the body of the car.
deleted by creator



