• 1 Post
  • 23 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: September 27th, 2023

help-circle
  • That is very valid point and I like that comparison of a wheel and car. I got lost in thinking how best revolutionary orgs can support strikes, because in my thought experiments it seems as though changing the modes of production would be the best way to support a strike. A diverse (in both profession and identity) group of workers who have all had a say in the demands that the strike is for and ready to work together because they have all been heard are essentially forming a new governance. Connecting, trusting and respecting one another despite the wildly cruel way the exploitation class attempt to divide us, can help the strike last much longer, and thus be more effective. However all of them “having a say” isn’t really part of the general strike, and agreeing to work with each other to promote the survival of the strike isn’t really part of the strike. Even a general strike just refers to denying capital our labour power. All that other stuff is just revolutionary support for a strike, like the engine and possibly the body of the car.




  • There’s the dead guy you don’t like. Afaik, ACE theory is just from the last ~30 years, so obviously that wasn’t developed to discuss yet. So I’m not impressed by an 1969 article, you’re not impressed by the comeback of a century old psych theory. Fair enough.

    In the realm of the hungry ghost is 15 years old. Adults of any age can report an ace score, things like divorce and cps file are hard evidence. Psychology is a science and science evolves, history does not. Even when people distort it, what happened, happened. All the same I can agree that it’s fair enough.

    Thanks you. I knew the idea, not the abbreviations. So the exchange wasn’t entirely wasted. I appreciate you confirming my suspicion on the hippie generation, and defining the abbreviation for me. I hope you have a good night and great sleep.

    Hope you have a good night too.


  • So I am willing to consider your PO perspective (because I actually may agree), and you’re talking about material evidence but want to drop this?

    I don’t like talking about dead people I don’t like.

    Religion is the opiate of the masses.

    I largely agree, but it’s not going to be a cold-turkey abstention.

    That completely depends on the addiction and the substance. Gabor Mate has written and spoken a great deal about it. There’s actually a 20 minute audio clip comparing his approach to addiction treatment with Jung’s, I’m not sure of it’s origin. Gabor Mate’s theory on addiction has ace (adverse childhood experience) scores to back it up.

    Opiates can save lives First I’ve heard of this.

    Anesthesia is the first one that comes to mind for me. I think surgery would be far more dangerous without the use anesthesia. There’s this recent study that shows opioids may no longer be needed for that though.

    MCM? Also what I just said.

    MCM (money->commodity->money^) refers to the capitalist ability to grow their money supply by using their money to by commodities (often including labour) and resell it for more than they paid for it. The difference in what they paid vs what they sell for is the surplus that they take from the workers and buyers. I think it’s like chapter 9 of Capital vol 1. It’s pretty easy to compare that to the workers general relation to money and commodities. Worker tend to use CMC, commodity money commodity. Sell labour for money, use money to buy groceries.


  • I would like to explore that. Can you give me some examples?

    As I have previously stated I don’t wish to continue talking about him, it seems to get in the way of a civil conversation.

    Marxism is based in material reality.

    So… Marx wasn’t a philosopher? I guess Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Buddhist ML’s have no place in your world.

    Of course Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Buddhist ML’s are completely acceptable in my world view. It’s just that as Marx said:

    Religion is the opiate of the masses.

    Opiates can save lives and they can just as easily destroy lives. So religion must be handle with extreme care. Of course Marx was a philosopher, but all of his work is based on material reality. Every premise he states is based on observable evidence, such as the state of the British working class. Every conclusion he makes is backed up by logical proofs. MCM doesn’t come from some feeling but is a description of an observable reality.






  • Glad you appreciated it. The flower power movement was disorganized and co-opted. However, it also lacked theory and involved alot of drugs, it was also more of cultural thing, the only real political position it held was anti-war.

    Building a revolution requires a clear head, the hippies had a CIA drugs faucet turned on them. This the British communist understanding of the hippie movement.

    MLK was beginning to shift from reformism to a more socialist stance but was assassinated as soon as he spoke against the Vietnam war, that stopped the civil rights movement from ever becoming truly revolutionary.

    The black panthers were an actually revolutionary socialist movement. They were hunted down and disparaged by a government at the height of it’s social, and material power. Racist tropes were used to make them terrifying to the white working class and uninitiated. Their neighborhoods also got the opium war treatment.

    There’s that old joke about the KGB and CIA officers having a friendly chat.

    CIA: “Your propaganda is pretty good.”

    KGB: “Thanks, yours is pretty good too.”

    CIA: Looking offended “What propaganda?”

    That shows just how little class awareness there was.

    *edit: I forgot to mention that many aspects of the hippy movement were as anti-worker as they were anti-capitalist.

    **edit: There was also no real crisis of capitalism at that time. That is typically required to start a revolution.


  • “As revolutionaries, we don’t have the right to say we are tired of explaining. We must never stop explaining. We know that when the people understand, they cannot help but follow us.” — Thomas Sankara

    There were 2 letters shared, one was from a high ranking PSL member Walter, the other was from an anonymous person who did not finish their candidacy.

    Walter’s letter doesn’t have a Lenin quotes, but the other does. Walter’s letter has some specific points but they fall apart under any amount of scrutiny. Walter’s letter reads like it was written by a fed as others have mentioned.

    Long winded response to the PSL Letters (Walter)

    These are the notes I took while reading the Letters Walter’s Letter Walter opens his with a few paragraphs talking about he has been dishearted in the past working at the party’s center. That tracks as he has a significant amount of writing that was published on Liberation News. The latest publication of his work there was published over a year ago. After that he begins complaining about Brian and Ben Becker and how much respect they seem to have from his fellow members. It kinda sounds like he’s jealous of Brian and Ben Becker.

    He than explains that the Branch Organizing Conference was the last straw for him. He claims that Brian established a central committee in an unsuccessful attempt to change the bylaws to make it easier to become a member. That could be a good thing as it could help grow the party. There is the unsubstantiated claim about how the leadership is against base building and mass organizing. He complains for quite a while about the leadership attempting to inspire hope and enthusiasm. He also makes the claim that a young union member gave a speech about how it was more important to distribute party literature than unionize and that speech was written by party leadership. That sounds suspicious to me, possible, and not great. Even the speech was written by leadership, it doesn’t really show that the party is anti-worker.

    He goes on to accuse the leadership of attempting to dissuade openly, than secretly base building projects. He also accused the leadership of sabotaging 2 community centers. It isn’t really clear if the leadership really opposed base building as whole or just some part the way they were building there. Then he complains about not being allowed to speak at a leadership retreat where others read speeches from their phones. Seems like a pretty common for speakers to keep their speeches on their phones, it’s a little off putting but everyone has to start somewhere.

    After that he complains that his loyalty was questioned, considering this letter, that makes alot of sense. Clearly the leadership didn’t agree with the way he wanted to do base building. Considering that not all base building is ethical, that really doesn’t prove much. Then he goes on to complain about the treatment of one of his allies in the base building thing. He goes on and on claiming the leadership will pretend to support base building and mass organizing, but behind closed do nothing but sabotage it. He mentions an unpublished document where he claims they were explicit about being against mass organizing and base building called turning to the working class. That document is not included.

    After that he seems to be disparaging the PSL’s efforts to make their views known. From what I’ve read of Marx and Lenin, that seems to generally speaking be the first step. Then he starts talking about the use of AI chatbots. While I disagree with their use, it is a kinda minor point, also frequently people are accused of using them even when they don’t.

    The next claim is possibly the most absurd, he claims that the US was closest to a socialist revolution in the late 1960s and early 1970s. That’s would be when cointelpro was targeting the black panthers. When CIA was killing all visible socialist leaders. The capitalists had complete control over the narrative. That was the height of US imperialism, historically socialist revolution would have a hard time forming at the height of empire in it’s core.

    He than goes on to claim that PSL developed a surveillance app disguised as organizing network. That sounds like a baseless conspiracy theory that the CIA came up with.

    Contradicting his earlier statement that the PSL members just talk about their ideas, he describes the liberation center he set up in Philadelphia. He explains that the liberation center is rooted in the neighborhood and runs various events to help working class people. After that he complains that are also used for PSL promotion. Completely ignoring that party promotion is necessary to building the revolution.

    In the section called why reforming the organization is impossible he complains about the gossip culture while saying all of these horrible things about leadership. He talks about how they one thing and do another, while he describes his own duplicity.

    After that in the section called why this can’t wait he seems to be blaming the PSL for Trump.

    The Response from the Central Committee The response starts off with a request to avoid republishing. Clearly that response was not respected.

    The psl is claims that the cohert leaving is has subscribe to reactionary doomerism, against their own revolutionary optimism. Considering how much Walter complained about the peppiness of the Branch Organizing Conference, I’d say that sounds pretty honest.

    The PSL than points out there are many NGOs and Unions doing exactly what he want the PSL and while many of them do good work, that is not the role has set out to play. The PSLs mission is to bring class consciousness to the masses so that they can form their own unions. To insist on leading the unionization efforts takes control away from the workers.

    The PSL also points out that Walter did not have these discussions with the leadership, this can also be verified by his own words at the start of his letter. He claims that he could not bring these issues to the leadership for fear of being pushed out.

    Walter was trying to do a hostile take over the Brooklyn office in secret, rather than doing any sort of organizing among the working class. All of his accusations are starting to look like confessions.

    According to the PSL he resigned when he did because there was about to be a debate, where he would have been caught. That would have lost Walters all sympathy and stunted his ability to recruit other members from the PSL.

    It also seems clear from the PSL’s response that Walter’s claim that women were constantly being complained about behind closed refers primarily to his own faction, not the leadership of the PSL.

    It sounds like the faction led by Walter is actively attempting to recruit PSL members around the country. It sounds like the PSL is completely done with Walters but is work is still up on Liberation News.

    The PSL response actually goes through many of Walters exact points and shows how they are either obviously false by logical contradiction, straight up lies, or mischaracterizations.

    After the rebuttal the PSL response brings up all of the ways they are responding to his few valid criticisms.

    Walter’s letter is not well reason and seems to be more about his distaste for Brian Becker to a point delusion. The few instances he describes as leading him to his conclusion are dripping with emotional language and most are completely refuted by the PSL.

    Couldn’t fit both response into one post.


  • Long winded response to My Letter of Withdrawal from the Party for Socialism and Liberation

    This person withdrew from the PSL a day before the PSL claims to have received Walters resignation. This person makes the claim that the PSL leadership doesn’t represent the common comrade. There is a repeated claim that there is no transparency, however they give a single example of situation where the PSL failed to be transparent. They just make vague claims of corruption. The PSL response detailed ways in which members can comment on any decision that is taken on by the central committee.

    There is also a disturbingly inaccurate summarization of the PSL’s response to Walter’s letter. This line in particular bothers me:

    There is only a superficial acknowledgement of “organizational issues,” while the purpose and intent of the criticisms are shifted to personal grievances and a “misunderstanding” of the party line. This shift away from the central thesis of Walter’s arguments, which are overwhelmingly and demonstrably not about a petty personal grievance or a misunderstanding of PSL’s “political line,” is manipulative and dishonest.

    Walter named numerous other people in the organization personally, that means he made it personal. The PSL pointed out that he had plenty of opportunities to voice his complaints, but that his complaints were kinda baseless. That’s not making it personal.

    In the next paragraph the author complains about the PSL’s participation in bourgeois elections. Lenin wrote about that in “Left-Wing” Communism: an Infantile Disorder. My understanding is that participation in bourgeois elections is occasionally appropriate for the revolutionary, just to show that it doesn’t work.

    The author claims that there has been a mobilization of PSL on social media, but I’ve seen nothing on any of their official sites. It’s possible some members have or maybe she referring to things said here. Walter didn’t really name pattern of structural rot, unless it’s his own. What he did was publicly make a bunch of unsubstantiated accusations and not only quit but took as people with him as he could, all while refusing to debate. That is sabotage, sabotage is done in secret, and he was working in secret to bring people to his seemingly counter revolutionary party. He created a factionalism within the party that planned to exploit by publicly calling it out when he left.

    The next part is really good because the author admits to never becoming a full member.

    I did not finish the candidacy classes necessary to become a “full” member, and this was deliberate

    The author claims that it was because the material was full of both theoretical and historical errors.

    The author brings up the general strike thing that Walter mentioned in his letter. The PSL’s response to it was rather telling, here’s their response.

    No matter that a general strike did actually take place. No matter that the Jan 30 shutdown actually advanced the living struggle of the masses and pushed back the Trump administration’s invasion.

    The author alleges that the PSL suffers from commandism and that the leadership is disconnected from the working class. Based on their response to the letter, they disagree. Based on my interactions with the PSL I would have to disagree.

    This letter appears to be encouraging a split from the PSL, that sounds like encouraging a sectarian split. However the paragraph where the author mentions the Bay Area Socialist, they state that sectarian splits are a great way to stop a revolutionary party from growing. That looks like a pretty major contradiction to me.

    The author claims that the PSL contains working class energy rather than organizing it. That’s like when the reactionaries try to discourage marching claiming that it doesn’t do anything. It takes effort to become a revolutionary, it takes time, it takes study. To successfully have a revolution we need the working class to understand that they have the power to change the system. We’re not there yet. The more we march, and engage in fully legal forms of revolution building the more successful our revolution will be and the faster we will achieve it.

    On to the actual letter which is much more well written than the preamble. I’ll start with the Lenin quote at the end of this section.

    “Those who have the slightest acquaintance with the actual state of our movement cannot but see that the wide spread of Marxism was accompanied by a certain lowering of the theoretical level. Quite a number of people with very little, and even a total lack of theoretical training joined the movement because of its practical significance and its practical successes… Without revolutionary theory there can be no revolutionary movement. This idea cannot be insisted upon too strongly at a time when the fashionable preaching of opportunism goes hand in hand with an infatuation for the narrowest forms of practical activity.“

    Candidates for membership of the PSL start off learning the theory as practiced by the PSL. So all members have at least some theory. I don’t know what the classes are like and the PSL could really use a book club. As noted in their response to Walter’s letter, the leadership doesn’t seem to have the bandwidth for that. The material circumstances of many members would make it nearly impossible to read all of the theory and engage in the actual work of building a revolutionary party.

    Here’s a Marx quote to counter

    The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways; the point is to change it.

    I’m still learning alot of the theory and the historical circumstances that have brought about successful revolutions, but it take a long time. Guiding principles can be picked up much more quickly though. The PSL I know tries it’s best to communicate to the working that their low wages are because of the oppression caused by various forms of chauvinism and oppression of the global south.

    About the Propaganda Complaint

    Attention, therefore, must be devoted principally to raising the workers to the level of revolutionaries; it is not at all our task to descend to the level of the ‘working masses’ as the Economists wish to do, or to the level of the ‘average worker’… You, gentlemen, who are so much concerned about the ‘average worker’, as a matter of fact, rather insult the workers by your desire to talk down to them when discussing working-class politics and working-class organisation. Talk about serious things in a serious manner; leave pedagogics to the pedagogues, and not to politicians and organisers!”

    I’m really not sure that I understand the author’s issue with the propaganda, the only examples the author mentions are statements that arose organically out to the masses. Without additional examples of the type of propaganda they are complaining about it’s really hard to know if there’s any weight to this argument. Also there was slight logical falicity that I can’t help but point out even though it’s likely just a typo.

    In fact, not all billionaires are capitalists, plenty of capitalists are millionaires or small business owners.

    Pretty sure they meant not all capitalist are billionaires, but that’s not what’s written. It is true that wealth and class are not the same thing. Though without a concrete example of the propaganda they are talking about, it’s not really a great point. Most of the propaganda I’ve seen is more about stating facts. Every rally I’ve been to hosted by the PSL had a variety of speakers not just party members.

    Failure to Convert Spontaneity into Action

    The Lenin wrote the letter author quotes was written just before the successful revolution in Moscow if I’m not mistaken. Class conciseness is growing but it is far from ready for that. There is also the complaint that party drops longer term projects for shorter term projects, that would hold a whole lot more weight if the author included an example of that. They claim that PSL should make demands at protests, but it seems to me that they do. They demand that US stop attacking Iran at that protest. The party should always be ready to respond and support a strike, but they are stretched thin.

    Participation in Bourgeois Elections

    The campaigns aren’t really about winning as much as raising awareness that there is a socialist party. In that regard they are effective. The PSL should also be working towards setting up more mutual aid networks, and other survival stuff. This still seems like strategic difference to me.

    The author concludes that the only acceptable option is to leave the party that they never became a full member of because the PSL failed their purity test.

    The author accuses the PSL of lacking theory, simplistic propaganda, failure to control spontaneity, and electorialism. I can’t judge the first point because no examples of the poor theory was presented, no specifics were given about the poor propaganda but I could at least browse their social media and didn’t see anything, the spontaneity thing seems like being a little over eager, and the last point is a difference in strategy. It’s clear that author is really leaving because they don’t feel like they are being heard. I would consider that an issue for their branch. They mentioned being able to have 6-10 people helping them with support from party leadership when they aren’t even a full member.


  • Those letters sound more like an opportunist attack on the PSL than actual criticism to me. My understanding of Right-opportunism is that it refers to sowing division amongst the working class as subtly as possible. Material conditions in the US for the past 70 years have been incredibly hostile to any sort of socialist movement. DSA and CPUSA were both heavily infiltrated, however their members, especially in the past few years, have been raising class consciousnesses. Breakthough news has alot of good content, but sometimes they get some stuff wrong.

    Vague claims that the leadership prevented the masses from base building doesn’t really do more than tell me there’s a disagreement. However, telling the DSA about how there Mamdani failed to arrest war criminals when Smotrich visited NYC, is an attempt to get them to stop relying on bourgeois electoralism. People need to be shown that voting in our current system isn’t going to solve the issue. The PSL seems to ask alot of it’s members, I don’t really know as I’ve never been a candidate though. I think they might have a problem with burnout.

    Marches aren’t counter revolutionary, they build revolutionary energy, networks, solidarity, and skill. On their own, they don’t do much, but they provide an avenue to start doing more.


  • People around here on Lemmygrad are doing an exact rerun of the “China supports Israel” psyop with Vietnam, a (lovely) country that does not respect sanctions on Iran…

    I’m confused. How is not supporting sanctions on Iran in support of Israel? Who is saying China supports Israel? I would like to see China cut Israel off completely, but I also understand that the cost of that might be too much for China. China has condemned Israel at the UN.



  • The only thing I know of that is comparable to what is happening in Palestine is what happened in the US to the people who were here first. PSL makes a point of acknowledging that. FREE (forum for real economic emancipation) also seems awesome. Building chapters based on their could be a key to building dual power which is nessicary for a successful revolution. All the groups even sketchy ones like DSA and cpusa need to come together. Something like free could allow that.


  • Oppression in the global south decreases the wages and employability of workers in the imperial core. I’ve definitely observed some chauvinism in the literature they propagate, however I am of the opinion, that is something they need to work on. Unequal exchange hurts all workers, while to unimaginable lesser extent those in the imperial core, they are still harmed by it. Focusing on the harm unequal exchange brings to workers of the imperial core, can allow them to become powerful allies.




  • I have been thinking alot about this lately. They’ve been one of the groups most willing to talk to me about what they believe in. They believe socialism can’t exist in only one country, that makes them one of the most of international groups out there. They also believe in permanent revolution.

    Long explanation of my thoughts on them

    DSA tells me it’s just a big umbrella party that wants to bring all the little parties together and has a history of associations with CIA and other plants that they seem to be actively trying to work past. It might be possible for them to return to a socialistic revolutionary stance, but anyone can see that they like the rest of the liberals could just as easily turn fascist. They are not an international organization. I could say more about them but the question was about Trotskyies.

    I don’t really know enough about CPUSA to talk about them beyond that they seem to limit their focus to the USA. They are also much smaller than the DSA but suffer from many of the same problems with infiltration. They painted a big target on their back.

    PSL also seems pretty US focused. They are kinda new on the scene, however they seem to be doing good work.

    All things considered I think the Trotskyies are one of the most principled and industrious socialists groups out there. They seem to be the ones most likely to invite you to their book club, and help you learn about socialist history, just remember all history is propaganda. Please understand the critique below relates to one of the most active groups of Trotskyies I’ve been talking to of late, it is not representative of all Trotskyies.

    The Trouble with Trotskyies

    • One of the most striking things they seem to believe is that Stalin betrayed the revolution. They’ll even go so far as to call Stalin a liberal. I would argue that while definitely made a number of serious mistakes, he did not betray the ideals of the revolutions. While I can believe Trotsky called Stalin a liberal, it’s hard for me to imagine anyone else doing so.

    Capital still had an iron grip on the world, Trotsky wanted to fight the revolution in every country but the Soviet Union didn’t have the resources for that at the time. They gave support to the revolution in China, I saw an episode of faith makes great about that. Cuba had support from the Soviet Union as well. I’m still studying this part of my socialist history though, any corrections and or expansions would be appreciated.

    • This group seemed to be trying to convince me that all governments were capitalist. Even countries like China, Cuba, Vietnam, and North Korean were complicit in the reproduction of capitalism. The argument went something like there are billionaires in China so the CPC is propagating capitalism, never mind that billionaires are punished in China when they act against the public good.

    This argument makes me wonder if they have lost sight of dialectal materialism. Some people are greedy and intelligent enough to find loop holes that allow them to build wealth in ways not controllable by the government. It takes time to figure out how to manage a prosperous system in way that limits inequality. The goal of socialism isn’t to make everyone poor. I haven’t seen much evidence that Tencent, BYD, or any other large cooperation in China is even capable of pressuring their government. Government officials that take any sort of bribe are severely punished. That limits the influence that capitalists can have on the government. The government is also the most effective institution that humanity has used to redistribute wealth (outside of maybe the church but I don’t think I need to go into the problems with that) that we have currently been able to utilize. My point you can’t build socialism without a strong government.

    • This group also attacks people for criticizing Abraham Lincoln.

    It’s amazing that all people seem to remember about Lincoln is that he freed the slaves by sign the emancipation proclamation. He is responsible for the largest mass execution of Native Americans in US history, and that says alot. Most states in the north had already abolished slavery by the time he became president. That was done by workers and slaves banding together to improve labor conditions. The bill Lincoln deserves no more credit for freeing the slaves than Bush deserves for same sex marriage, or Richard Nixon deserves for establishing the epa. Defending Lincoln to that extent reeks of great man theory and disrespect to the workers.

    Why Bother with Trotskyies

    • They tend to be the most international.

    I’m not sure there are chapters for any of the other socialists organizations that are in my area in other countries. I know that the PSL, and probably others send support to places like Cuba. However that is very different from actually having members in other countries.

    • Their organizations are far more experienced and battle harden than any other group I know of.

    These people have a recorded history going back nearly century of supporting unions, building unions, and standing up for the working class. They know how to do what needs to be done to get the job done. Trotsky did lead the red army.

    • Despite my complaints about some of their rhetoric, they are extremely principled.

    All of the Trotskies I’ve met have been extremely willing to listen to my complaints. They have every reason to be suspicious of other socialists organizations, they’ll ready to fight anyone at the first sign of corruption. Doesn’t matter if it’s corrupt union leaders or politicians. That corruption should be called out, though I think they’d get more mileage out of doing it abit more tactfully.

    I would like to see Trotskies stop calling the rest of Stalinist, and help the rest of us start building the socialist revolution of the 21st before capitalism drives our species to extinction. I haven’t been able to stop thinking about this for months. Maybe that’s just me. Thanks for reading my mad ramblings.