My situation is this: I’ve actually had depressive/PTSD Symptoms since I was a teenager. Both my parents were abusive. I started figuring out my childhood wasn’t normal in my twenties and have been in and out of therapy since then. The diagnosis was always “depression” or “recurring depressive episodes”. It got really really bad this March. I looked for a new therapist but also into the possibility of an inpatient facility. I found a therapist who was also OK with me going to the hospital for a while during our therapy. Great. After our first session I actually got the OK for the clinic provided I can come within two weeks. I call my therapist, all good, we’ll resume after I’m back. The clinic helped a ton. I learned a lot that I found helpful and got the offcial diagnosis PTSD and inofficial cPTSD (which won’t be official until the ICD11 is fully out in Germany). That explains a lot. I gave my therapist all the paperwork from the clinic.
Here comes my problem: I am describing my problems to her in the new vocabulary I’ve learned at the clinic and also my understanding of where these problems come from. I’ve also told her that the methods from the clinic help me maybe 40%, but I feel like I need a different approach. She suggested her approach and I said OK. Now whenever I describe my problems in the vocabulary I’ve learned she stops me and says “that is not how I work. I don’t work with the concepts of Inner critic or reframing what the inner critic says.” So I said “I also don’t feel like it’s helping me, but that’s how I’ve learned to describe my problems. How else can I describe what I’m feeling?” She never gives me a straight answer. Just some vague “Just describe your problems” and that the terms “inner critic” and other terms I use belong to a different school of thought.
Anyway, last session we had the same problem, I used some vocabulary that belong to a method she doesn’t like or use. And she told me point blank I should reconsider if she’s the right therapist for me, if I insist on wanting to use the other therapy approach. I’ve tried explaining that I don’t want to use the other approach, I don’t feel like it’s helping me long term, it’s just that I use these terms to describe my problems. I don’t feel like she understood, she just kept insisting that she’s the wrong therapist for me as I don’t want to follow her method.
I feel like shit and I don’t even know what I did wrong. I don’t understand what she’s expexting of me. I also don’t feel like I have the strength to start searching for a therapist again. Any advice? I don’t even know exactly what I’m doing wrong and I’m unsure if I really understand what she expects of me.
A lot of therapists aren’t very good.
If yours won’t engage with your clinic based treatment, and makes you feel worse you should try another one.
Maybe the clinic has a list of therapists they’ve worked with in the past?
I have been going to psychologists since I hit puberty, and here is one big thing I have learned from that: for most of them, it’s just a job. They clock in, they go through the motions, they clock out. I am incredibly lucky to have found my current psychologist. Not only is he deeply passionate about it, he is also a great fit for me. One thing he has said to me many times is that he always tries to meet his client where they are, instead of trying to force them into his mindset. If your psychologist has a preferred mode of doing things, that’s fine. But then the onus is on her to communicate her preferences and expectations clearly and directly. Ask her for the specific, technical name of the theoretical framework she wants to use (for example, Cognitive Behavioural Therapy, Schema Therapy, Gestalt Therapy, et cetera). Ask her to explain it to you as if you were a student. Then go home and look it up on the internet. That way, you can make an informed choice.
I don’t think I’ve ever encountered any medical personnel who didn’t approve of describing it as an “inner critic” (or variations on that), how weird.
Anyway, I honestly can’t see anything you could have done differently. You had an issue and you brought it up with her, now it’s her job to explain what she wants you to do, in terms you can understand. She’s not doing that job.
Unfortunately, I can’t see what else to do other than find a new therapist. That’s devastating and I wish I had absolutely anything else to say. Sometimes it just doesn’t work out with a therapist.
They’re probably trying to get you to develop your own vocabulary. Mind games are immature though, and the basis of effective communication is a shared vocabulary. A skilled practitioner would work with you where you’re at. They’re likely young (or old) and attached to their own modality in a way that reduces their effectiveness. Find someone else.
definitely trust your instinct to talk to another therapist. I can’t speak to inpatient stuff, but I’m 100% sure you need to be on the same page communications wise with your therapist, and it is clear they’re not willing to get there with their “style” of therapy.
Your mistake was simply assuming that because they are a therapist that they would be capable of helping you. Virtually all of them can only do the bare minimum; try again, you’ll find one that works much better
It sounds like you need to talk to the in patient clinic to find out where the terminology that you learned came from and what the method that you preferred is called. Then ask them for suggestions for a new therapist that uses that method. If they don’t have any, then start contacting therapists and ask them about the method until you find one who uses it. You can also try a web search by method, e.g. “cognitive behavioral therapists near me.”
If you are in Germany, what kind of approach is she using? If it is Verhaltenstherapie, maybe thinking about using “automatic” instead of “unconscious” and “automatic negative thoughts” instead of “inner critic” could solve the problem (although I find that highly unlikely, because it is really strange for a therapist to discourage a client to use such words and bring unable to explain what they want). Thus, instead of using words that describe imagined persons, you could try using words that describe learned automatic behavior.
However, I really don’t know if that would solve the problem, as her behavior is so…unusual for a therapist. But I could imagine a CBT therapist who previously worked at a university having such a specific mindset after research papers bring rejected for the wrong choice of words.
Find a new therapist. If you met someone randomly off the street you wouldn’t necessarily like them or get along with them. Therapy is the same - notnegery therapist is the same and not every therapist fits the patient.
It sounds like neither you nor the therapist feels this is working. So find a therapist that does work for you.
Also CBT specifically may be what you’re looking for if you find the concept of the inner critic something that makes sense to you, and something you can work with.

