• 2 Posts
  • 86 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 18th, 2023

help-circle

  • Vegan leather is not as durable as a normal plastic made for covers. It’s generally made of Mycelium (mylo) the specific Xiaomi vegan leather is made in part of apple peel.
    The term Vegan leather is reserved for “sustainable” materials, which means it can be made of reused plastic. But that’s still not as strong as the high end plastic materials that was originally used for premium phones.
    If I knew for sure the vegan option for the phone was made of high quality PU, I would have chosen that.




  • Wow way to misrepresent what I wrote. No I don’t “regularly” drop my phone, But it happens, and when it does it has ALWAYS been from a sitting position sliding out of my pants pocket, making the drop only about 30-45 cm. Most drop tests are done at 1m, and since the damage is exponential to the height, a drop of 30 cm maybe 3 or 4 times in the lifespan of the phone shouldn’t be a problem.

    But thanks for the strawman argument.


  • If you’ve got a glass phone without a case or insurance then you kinda running this risk.

    Yes I know, but I’ve never had any problems at all, I’ve never dropped the phone out of my hands, so I considered the risk to be very low. I must admit I’m shocked the phone cracked from such a minor drop.

    Once it’s getting towards the end I purposely wreck the phone off a wall and get brand new

    That’s fraud.

    Edit PS.

    Note this is the only time I’ve dropped this phone. When I mention it happens, it’s maybe a couple of times in a year, I’ve never really dropped my phone while holding it, it’s always slipped out of my pocket, it’s happened when I drive, I think it’s first time ever it happened on the terace.



  • Even you:

    No I didn’t fall for it, it was absolutely on the negative list, and I’ve avoided glass backs on all my previous phones, but this time I couldn’t, without making heavy compromises in other areas.
    Except for the Vegan leather, which is almost guaranteed to become ugly within a year. So I bet on the glass as the lesser of 2 evils.

    Good for you for calling them out on their bullshit.

    Thanks, I’ve actually done that since 2011.

    Just remember, if you fell for this one, you might fall for another marketing gimmick unless you pay more attention.

    I didn’t fall for it, it was the least bad option I thought, because otherwise I’d have to compromise on other things.



  • My Moto held brilliantly without being ruggedized and without a case. And that’s despite it is big 6.8" screen and relatively heavy with 220 grams.

    I’d say it’s absolutely a flaw, to chose a material that is way way worse and yet more expensive.
    As I write in my post, with a case, there is zero advantage to the glass back, and you don’t get any premium feel from it.



  • Another thing is that now they make “vegan leather” as the new “premium feel”, which of course won’t break like glass, but it still doesn’t have nearly the durability of a decent synthetic/plastic back, which IMO feels great to hold and makes the phone lighter and despite being better it’s cheaper.

    With the glass you get extra weight, and with a cover, you get extra bulk and weight on top of that.
    It’s drives me nuts how insane this design decision to use glass is! Vegan Leather isn’t that much better, I had the LG G4 with leather back, and it got pretty ugly after a couple of years. But at least that could be easily changed/swapped by the user. And according to every source I can find, vegan leather has lower durability than real leather.