• 0 Posts
  • 214 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 7th, 2025

help-circle
  • Yeah, this is it. I appreciate the uncertain language of whether or not centrism “won” the 1992 election as well. It really is just an oversimplification where everyone but the establishment loses. The results from the last decade or so should be data enough to show that the way things are measured is fundamentally broken. While the whole left/right liberal/conservative paradigm is still the pervading “default” mode of thinking in the meta of American Politics, but it’s increasingly coming under more scrutiny, especially after this last election once again failed to produce predictions that had the results within their parameters. I think a good portion of that lies in this weird idea that many dem and even academic circles are getting recently that “populism is a right-wing thing”, which is once again predicated on the paradigm of left/right liberal/conservative. Almost like people really aren’t that simple or something…







  • This is such a silly take. If humans ought to have better priorities than infinite growth, then the problem is whatever necessitates the premise of infinite growth. Infinite growth is not only unnecessary in being defined as human, but even detrimental to human existence. The problem you’re blaming on humans is capitalism. Capitalism is the plague.

    “Fallen World” does not give abrahamic religions license to consume infinitely. It has nothing to do with consumption, but rather to build the premises of why their religion is necessary for “salvation”. Abrahamic religions have plenty of ridiculous and immoral things to critique about them, just be sure to pick a real one.



  • Well, I just reread my comment and realized it could be interpreted to mean I think MMT and economics in general is all bullshit, but I poorly worded it. I actually generally subscribe to MMT myself with some caveats here and there. I was more trying to get at how MMT is great at demonstrating how little economic value is measured by truly objective standards and the dollar only has value because we think it does. Many economists out there would seem to have you believe they have the same predictive power as the field of physics, but like… lol.

    Yeah, agreed that economics is necessary as a field of study, and hard agree on Unlearning Economics being a great channel to have a healthy approach to economics in general. Sorry about my poor wording above, but it does appear we don’t really have any disagreement here. Also, I could be wrong; we’re getting into economics afterall.






  • Man, this is a great example of “you’re not wrong, you’re just an asshole”.

    Does the internet in general(not just lemmy) constantly feed that negativity bias? Oh, absolutely. Hard agree that’s probably one of the biggest problems in society in general right now.

    Have people in general and especially in the west list perspective because we’ve had it so good for awhile? Hoo boy, hard agree again.

    But uhh… yeah, this is a shitpost community. Time and place. Also, I know it seems a bit pedantic, but it is important; science doesn’t “prove” shit. Science is a method and a tool to help us better refine knowledge. It’s important you actually point to the studies.


  • NoTagBacks@lemmy.dbzer0.comtoBluesky@lemmy.world•Maturing
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    2 months ago

    There’s so much to address here, it’s crazy. I’ll give it a shot, I guess.

    Incentive in this context is not really that relevant. Sure, Incentivization of systems and all that, but in terms of actual outcomes and how people make decisions, incentives are a terrible predictor of behavior and motive. Additionally, to try and say the one factor is all that matters is ridiculous.

    To dismiss morality and my original subject of how dumb some legislators are, conflate incentive and motive as one thing and the only legitimate explanation of evil legislative decisions, then conclude that people are inherently(or even just predisposed to) evil because power is uhh… yeah, that’s pretty wild.

    You also state that I believe people can/do resist abusing their power. This is a non-starter as nothing I said even suggests such a thing, you made that up. On top of that, I can explicitly state that is, in fact, not my position on the topic of abuse of power. I already reject the framing of power and abuse of it as presented in your comment before any argument is even made. There’s so much more to it than just “power corrupts”. And power isn’t even a factor for many people anyway, even in the context of being in a position of power. People as a whole really aren’t that simple.

    The only thing I was getting at is that there are people in decision-making positions that appear to make a decision because they’re evil or corrupt or whatever else, but in reality, they’re just really dumb. This doesn’t exclude other factors, nor does this make a definitive statement about reality, it’s just an observation from my experience in politics challenging a common incredulity that “they can’t really be that stupid” to which I’m backing up the common saying “never attribute to malice what can sufficiently be explained by stupidity”.



  • NoTagBacks@lemmy.dbzer0.comtoBluesky@lemmy.world•Maturing
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    58
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    3 months ago

    It’s funny because I agree and disagree at the same time. I’ve had varying levels of “there’s way more nuance to this” and “how the fuck is everyone complicating this???” throughout my life and have generally come to the conclusion that it’s much more complex than that in that everything is both more nuanced and more simple at the same time because politics really is that stupid.

    However, in getting involved in political circles and actually getting to know some legitimate decision makers toward the top, some of these fuckers are way more stupid than we think. Like, alarmingly so. I’ve had moments where some GOP dumbfuck is doing some evil shit and I’m like “I don’t think they’re doing this maliciously” and some of my more partisan left-ish friends get all offended think I’m defending them, when really it’s so much worse; they’re doing it because they’re legitimately really fucking stupid… and they’re part of world leadership. Don’t get me wrong, some of them are both stupid and an asshole, but at the end of the day, people in general tend to get the overall picture of politics wrong because it’s way more nuanced in how fucking stupid it is.

    One more fun thought for y’all: many of the really dumb legislators I’ve met in the past predate the current GOP alignment. And you see how much dumber the current GOP is versus the GOP of not even a decade ago? Well…


  • I don’t think I have a well-informed opinion on them, but from my current understanding, they seem to be poorly deployed as it is. There’s more to explore about them for me, such as whether or not we have a good understanding/ proposal of an optimal deployment, environmental impact, cost/benefit versus other methods, how much of this is a cash-grab by opportunist dickheads, is/will/can there be earnest good-faith deployment as a solution, is this just another solution looking for a problem, is this a viable stepping stone to something better, are the premises of advocation sound/valid, are there other factors that aren’t obvious that merit consideration, what does current world implementation(s) look like, is it working, what does the data look like, is it good data, is it adequate data, etc,etc,ect. I’m less so trying to make the point that I don’t know enough so much as making the point of what it takes to bring into consideration yet another variable in an already saturated conversation about transportation, especially considering the poor dissemination of information of what we already know/understand well.

    I’m not trying to be dismissive, and I’m sure e-scooters have their place in an ideal world, but given the current social/political context, I don’t think they’re relevant as a public topic if the goal in mind is to improve the glaring transportation issues we have today. And I suspect that part of the point of pushing e-scooters is indeed to create another red herring in the fight against fossil fuels and car-centric everything, though I will admit that such a notion is speculative on my part since, again, I haven’t done an adequate amount of looking into it to form a worthy opinion.



  • Y’all, this is one of those articles worth reading right quick. The title is… well, bad. They were looking more at the “quality” rather than quantity of social media usage. The findings were more about the reinforcement of the user’s state rather than social media itself being bad. Sure, the algorithm will push things, but your algorithm is primarily gonna push what it needs to keep you engaged with itself, and what you engage with will be influenced by your state of mind/mood. If you’re already depressed, you’re probably gonna reinforce that via the algorithm. Same deal with positive outlooks. Neuroplasticity and all that.

    The researchers also bring up a good point about calling into question the recommendation to limit the amount of time on social media with the idea of mitigating the negative effects. Much like [alcohol] prohibition in the US, a ban on social media usage does nothing to teach us a more wise and healthy approach, nor is it something realistic for the general population.

    In fact, if we practice abstention in such a way, those that would use it for malignant purposes would make it worse. I think a good example of that is cryptocurrency. Crypto isn’t inherently bad, but boy did it get super maligned by any left-leaning space. There are plenty of useful things we could do with crypto, especially now with the hostile behavior of many currency-issuing states, but since crypto was mostly abandoned by leftist spaces, scams, commodification, speculation, and other hyper-capitalist bullshit abounds in the crypto space.

    Do we really want to cede the further development of social media to malignant dickheads via unwitting abstention? Or will we take the time to actually learn how to wisely approach the tools we have right in front of us?