• 8 Posts
  • 27 Comments
Joined 9 个月前
cake
Cake day: 2026年2月17日

help-circle
  • Speaking from my Nondualist background: Learning astral projection (if such a thing is possible) is a very different endeavor from gaining knowledge of the universe. Usually pursuit of such siddhis is considered a distraction.

    Also, I wouldn’t recommend learning meditation from someone who can’t show they have been authorized to teach it. At a quick glance, I can’t really find out anything about this guy’s background, just a lot of new age noise. This is a red flag. Importantly, what they are offering seems to be all over the place. If your goal is gain knowledge of the universe, find a teacher who is focused on that. See the Guide in the sticky for some pointers.

    Names that pop to mind also for you are Andrew Holecek (for the Astral Projection), Loch Kelly and Headless Way.

    As for the sound issue - stop doing the meditation. That’s generally a good rule of thumb, especially if you can’t consult the teacher themselves about it.



  • I don’t know that “most” do this. It’s just that obviously you’re not going to notice the ones that don’t do it. But yes, it’s a real issue and one of the reasons I’m not on board with the “I’m my own guru” sentiment or avoiding communities. That’s usually a great way of isolating one-self from healthy feedback. Of course there’s the flip side that teachers can be corrupt and communities can be cults but I’d say in this day of hyper-individualism and algorithm based spirituality, spiritual bypassing is the bigger problem. Of course you can have a spiritually bypassy collective but ehh… those are more likely to also get called out these days, thanks to social media.

    You might enjoy Near Enemies of The Truth and Opening The Heart of Compassion. They get into the topic.







  • Not at all. That’s just how the manosphere corrupted it. Stoicism often aims to reframe situations that make certain feelings arise (which is how it’s utilized in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy), but also, if some feelings arise, it also teaches acceptance of them, without letting them control your behavior. Stocism teaches feelings are natural and inevitable (e.g., grief, anger), but our reactions to them are within our control. You can still be angry, but that doesn’t have to lead to unwise behavior. The goal isn’t to avoid the first but to shape the second. You CAN actually just feel your feelings, or express them in healthy ways when expression is called for.

    Seneca: “The wise man is not immune to emotions, but he is not overwhelmed by them. He feels them, but he does not follow them. He acknowledges their presence, but he does not let them dictate his actions.”

    That said, I’m not a Stoic myself but I see the parallels with Buddhism and certain branches of Hinduism. There’s the general theme of radical acceptance of reality as it is, and having wisdom around picking your battles.








  • YES!!! Dancing has been a huge part of many cultures in the world since time immemorial. For every occasion and emotion! My pet hypothesis is that it particularly fell out of favor in the west (as a purposeful practice) because of Christian influence and the mind-body split. Some peoples even dance in funerals as an expression of grief.

    It’s coming back a bit now but though it’s slightly hindered by the associations with new ageism etc. but I really wish people didn’t let that stop them from trying it. It does have clear benefits. You can use any kind of music. You don’t have to know how to dance. Just move the body with whatever music you like.

    I dance at least a little every day, even if I don’t feel like it. And I very purposefully dance to aggressive music when I’m angry because I have a temper, and I don’t want it get the better of me. It has worked really well.

    Edit: Not to devalue talking about your feelings at all btw. But a lot of people struggle with intellectualizing their emotions to the point they can’t connect to them at all in their body. You need a balance.






  • Just gave my view on the matter with precise language.

    I made a distinction between a description of a subjective experience, and a claim about consensus reality.

    People experience something and then use the best language available to talk about it. These experiences are viscerally real to the experiencer.

    Vast majority of people will reasonably make a claim about consensus reality if they experience something that feels very real. Because vast majority of people don’t know or understand that you CAN have a very visceral subjective experience that only happens in the brain. Or to put it another way: the brain behaves in a way that gives one every reason to think the experience happened in consensus reality.

    It doesn’t make them “crazy” or “stupid”. But again, because most people don’t understand the distinction between a subjective experience and consensus reality, it’s easy to be dismissive of people who talk about outlandish experiences.

    It would be more rational and kind to meet in the middle: “I believe you had an experience, but I don’t believe it means Aliens exist in consensus reality.”



  • The goal of meditation isn’t an empty mind though. It’s a common misconception. Not sure if this is your case of course.

    Flow state is considered spiritual though, yes. But it’s not necessarily the state all meditations seek.

    Flow state is a hyper focused meditative state. It’s also possible to have a hyper open meditative state, such as noticing thoughts and everything else that arises.

    People interested in spirituality usually practice both 🙂