The whole thing is dumb if you accept a premise of “infinite monkeys”.

If thats the point where you want to draw the line, I guess that it becomes dumb at exactly that point.

But the point of the thought experiment is that it says what you said: it will definitelly happen because infinity is absurdly big number.

Spliting from within the party is the usual way.

It is when you use cova cola instead of, lolipop, santa, flag, flower or some other red object.

It’s somehiw obvious now, but the question appeared 25 centuries ago when it wasn’t even remotely clear what was the answer.