• 0 Posts
  • 320 Comments
Joined 2 months ago
cake
Cake day: October 4th, 2026

help-circle


  • Art is not meant to be an expression of humanity.

    Creativity in general is something anything can do. Human, animal or other wise.

    The humanity element is the self expression through art.

    The self expression is what makes it “art” as is generally thought of.

    But there is absolutely nothing that stops an animal, robot, or act of nature and happen stance from also generating art.

    The random whims and circumstances of nature creating a beautiful landscape or a ugly one. Both are in themselves art. But they aren’t human art.

    A machine generating a horrifically generic bland and boring copy paste of algorithmically mundane slop or a accidentally beautiful rendering of a sunflower both are their own kinds of art.

    But they aren’t HUMAN art.

    Nature and machine can’t express themselves, there’s no ego to express. People focus too much on what’s making the art while at the same time absolutely ignoring why they are focusing on it.

    I would never say a machine generated picture is the same kind of art as a human. It fundamentally can’t be. Unless a human transformation the picture the machine generated and curates it.

    But then you don’t have a machine generated picture you just have human art that used a tool.

    Intend and expression are what makes art what it is.

    If you only care about the final put put. Then what make it does not matter at all.

    And for some things that is fine. If you need a flat simple UI to do a functional job. That doesn’t need an artist, it needs a product. And machine or human can both make a product.