Since yesterday I’ve basically been crippled by thoughts about suffering which is inherent in our nature, and is not solvable in an ethical manner. I can’t really think of or do anything else.
This does not (in this case…) concern the suffering caused by humans, which can – at least to some degree – be mitigated.

I’ll try to keep it short.
Basically, I just thought of the relationship between predators and prey. The prey might eventually escape, but possibly with extreme and awful injuries. Or if the predator is successful, it might end up being ripped apart while still alive.
That is horrible, and creates strong feeling of compassion for the prey.
BUT, that’s only true if focusing on the prey. Let’s now imagine the predator’s side. Possibly starving, also injured from unsuccessful fights, possibly even with hungry young offspring waiting for their parent (the predator) to bring them some food so they don’t starve as well.
Which is what makes it shitty – it sucks, yet there is no (ethical) solution.

I’ve also questioned the ethics re-introducing predators to areas where they were made extinct, compared to something like contraceptive population control. Doing it (eliminating predators) on purpose would (in my opinion) not be ethical, as we’d have to destroy life (as we already did in many places). But in places where this was already done, could it be a more ideal method of population control?

Lastly, there’s a question of general human involvement in nature. While this wasn’t originally a concern I had, some people in discussions I looked up had mentioned it as well.
This concerns if, and if so, up to what degree is intervention ethical.
E.g.: Only helping if harm was caused by humans, vaccinating against rabies, removing parasites, treating injuries, etc.
I.e.: Where should a line be drawn.


Welp. Possibly it should be easy to not think about, considering the many atrocities happening. However, there being something worse (in terms of suffering), doesn’t make something awful better.

This has also led me to discover something called Negative Utilitarianism, which is a view of prioritizing the minimization of suffering.
But just like Utilitarianism, which aims to maximize happiness, it results in some absurd outcomes.
More specifically, one outcome. A 100% solution to ending all suffering – annihilating all life.
While being technically correct, it is a quite absurd solution.

In online discussions I’ve also found people compare the suffering caused by such a “solution” to the total suffering of continued life.
But that brings me to question whether it’s even possible to quantify and calculate suffering of multiple people.

Let’s say 11 people show up with some injuries. They are asked to rate their pain on a scale of 1 to 10. There’s 10 people with a paper cut who consider their pain a 1. The last one is a person with an open fracture, who considers their pain to be a 10. Is their suffering equal and comparable?
This would only get more absurd on a larger scale.


So yes, I am going a bit insane. Horrors within my comprehension, some without a solution. I wish to have not been born.

  • rah
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    4 hours ago

    crippled by thoughts about suffering which is inherent in our nature, and is not solvable in an ethical manner. I can’t really think of or do anything else.

    That’ll pass.