• 354 Posts
  • 851 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: January 3rd, 2024

help-circle

  • imo this drama was set up intentionally, the SSPX is controlled opposition and kind of “fake resistance” to Vatican 2

    reposting a comment of sorts:

    SSPX imo is set up as false opposition (like Vigano)

    The Vatican represents a false Catholicism currently [the Vatican 2 modernism]

    The SSPX takes a halfway measure into a “schismatic no man’s land”, where they recognize the Vatican as Catholic and openly disobey the Vatican [usually a Catholic would either recognize and obey, or not recognize and “resist” - SSPX picks a middle contradictory position in our view]

    If one by obeying the Vatican is led towards an “anti-Catholic way of life”, then it seems our logical conclusion is “sedevacantism”, or that the Vatican is not to be considered as Catholic or to be obeyed

    Recap again:

    Vatican leads people into an anti-Catholic modernism

    SSPX leads people into an anti-Catholic “schismatic resistance to the Vatican”

    I think the correct Catholic response to these therefore must be something else then (like “sedevacantism”)





  • I see they have kept the downvotes on this instance

    (I don’t think that’s a practical move but, here we are)

    “I always think of myself as a Christian who hates Christianity.”

    I find that relatable; he’s presenting himself as maybe wanting Christianity to be better and hating the status quo of what passes for “Christianity”.

    However, conservatives will also rightly interpret this to mean he just identifies as Christian without following Christian teachings and with changing them in unChristian ways.

    tbh I haven’t been following his politics at all so I don’t know much of the situation





  • from some redditalternatives comments it looks like reddit is overrun with bots

    and lemmy is a thing but still probably a lot of biased leftwing stuff (besides instances like here - I haven’t been active, have more instances popped up that are decent?)

    and then there’s a lot of basically vibecoded-tier forums which are gonna be small and niche

    and that’s the internet for us right now or you know of other things besides what I’ve listed